The Onion Model of Human Factors: A Theoretical Framework for Cross-Cultural Design SpringerLink

Posted On October 19, 2023

DEV Community — A constructive and inclusive social network for software developers. To me, tests are the fragile skin around the onion, that everyone immediately throws in the bin. “Being Agile” and “being predictable” may seem mutually exclusive, at least when it comes to product management. Traditional planning methods typically follow fixed cycles, with those cycles often occurring very far apart. It consists of algorithms that are essential to its purpose and implement the use cases that are the heart of the application. The parts of your code that expose your application to the outside world are also part of the Infrastructure Layer, as they deal with IO.

onion model software

We also create a generic repository, and add queries to retrieve data from the source, map the data from data source to a business entity, and persist changes in the business entity to the data source. To illustrate the layer architecture, we will analyze a Layer.Factory code sample that is available on github [13]. The Layer.Factory sample is a very simple Domain Driven Design sample application which follows the layered architecture pattern. The idea is that the domain model behind it represents a factory which produces layers (what a coincidence). In order to be able to create layers a factory responsible for creating layers must be created first.

What are the Layers of the Onion Architecture?

Generally speaking, you’ll plan at the lower levels most often but progressively slow your planning as you move towards the higher levels. For example, while your daily planning is likely to occur, well…daily, you may only need to revisit your product vision every few months or even annually. At the top of the Planning Onion, we have the visioning layer. In this layer, the goal is to define the overarching problems your product is solving as well as for whom it is solving those problems. Considering these questions at the outset will help you understand the true value your product brings to users as well as how your product might differentiate itself from other products attempting to solve the same problems. For example, a team planning on an annual cycle might define their entire strategy for the upcoming year in a single session in January.

Whether or not the organization’s strategies are effective, however, is determined largely by the underlying layers which tend to influence their nature. Once data has been generated, it needs to be made accessible to those who can use it. Though we live in a data of era abundance, all too often data generated resides in silos controlled and monetized by companies. New models for collaborating and accessing public and private-sector data, such as open data platforms or data collaboratives, can break these silos. Create onion diagrams like this template called Onion Diagram 20 in minutes with SmartDraw. SmartDraw includes onion diagrams templates you can customize and insert into Office.

Infrastructure Layer

However, even agile teams who aren’t following a Scrum approach tend to do some form of iteration-level planning by selecting and planning their upcoming work in small batches. Onion architecture might seem hard in beginning but is widely accepted in the industry. It is a powerful architecture and enables easy evolution of software.

onion model software

Finally, at the core of the organization is the organization’s personnel. The overall effectiveness of the organization and its ability to survive a crisis is dependent on each human resource. The everyday operation of the organization determines how susceptible it will be to a crisis and forms the underpinnings of any crisis management plan. If appropriate infrastructure is not in place, the organization could prove to be volatile and will be unable to support an effective crisis management strategy even if one is in place at layer four.

Making Agile Planning Work With Your Team

During this session, they might not only define their goals for the year, but also a detailed plan for achieving those goals. And they’d likely assign just as much specificity to their plans for December as their plans for January. By the end of the session, everyone agrees the resulting plan will chart their course forward for the next year. Teams who invest time in proper planning tend to have a better understanding of long-term goals for the product, and more realistic strategies for achieving those goals. Low coupling in which one module interacts with another module and does not need to be concerned with the other module’s internals. All the internal layers need not be concerned about internal implementation of external layers.

When working with Scrum, you will probably want to break the development of the software into different tasks, so it can be done by different people. By doing dependency injection in all the code, everything becomes easier to test. The application’s entrypoint (usually, the main) should be responsible for instantiating all necessary dependencies and injecting them into your code. The inner layers shouldn’t know if your application is being exposed through an API, through a CLI, or whatever.

Start by modeling the database

We can see in that simple example that refactoring from a layered architecture to an onion architecture is not enough in order to get a true onion architecture. In order to get rid of this dependency we would what is onion architecture need to introduce a small abstraction (interface) defined by the needs of the Core. Each layer/circle encapsulates or hides internal implementation details and exposes an interface to the outer layer.

onion model software

Classes, methods, variables, and source code in general belonging to the outer circle depends on the inner circle but not vice versa. Onion Architecture solved these problem by defining layers from the core to the Infrastructure. It applies the fundamental rule by moving all coupling towards the center. This architecture is undoubtedly biased toward object-oriented programming, and it puts objects before all others. At the center of Onion Architecture is the domain model, which represents the business and behavior objects. Around the domain layer are other layers, with more behaviors.

Product Design Onion Diagram Template

Other books or articles may name it differently but we will stick to that definition. We have the presentation or client layer, the process or service layer, the domain or business logic layer, the data access or infrastructure layer. Sometimes you see the layers above extended with another layer sitting on the left side spawning all layers. This layer is often called crosscutting layer which handles tracing, logging and more. Onion architecture is built on a domain model in which layers are connected through interfaces.

  • Onion Architecture addresses the challenges faced with 3-tier and n-tier architectures, and to provide a solution for common problems.
  • Based on cultural “onion and iceberg” models and the dimensions of human factors, the present paper proposed the “onion model” of human factors as a framework to guide related activities of cross-cultural design.
  • Let’s understand different layers of the architecture and their responsibilities with an order creation use case.
  • As with all software problems, we need to evaluate whether or not we need this additional abstraction as it is more suited for larger applications with many engineers working on them.
  • It’s the outer-most layer, and keeps peripheral concerns like UI and tests.
  • That’s equally true on a macro level (i.e. company wide) as it is on a team or even individual level where the product might be a deliverable to a downstream team or a tool for internal use.
  • One of the core concepts in DDD is the Domain Model.A Domain Model is an entity that incorporates behavior and data from some business model.

The Infrastructure Layer uses them, but is does not create them. If you have a repository that expects a PostgreSQL client, the main should instantiate it and pass it to the repository during its initialization. DTOs are well suited as objects with really specific formats and data. Your Domain models can have Value objects in their attributes, but the opposite is not allowed.

The Onion

A great way to do this is collaboratively completing a product vision canvas with the leaders of your organization. There are many great canvases available, but my personal favorite is the Product Vision Board by Roman Pichler, as this canvas can help your team focus on the questions they need to answer to be successful. Also, the code is easier to test due to dependency injection, which also contributes to making the software more maintainable. So, the only place in your application that actually creates objects that are capable of doing IO is the application’s entrypoint.

Finally, these values can be best achieved by embracing an approach to open data that facilitates them. But despite everyone’s best intentions, sooner or later, reality will strike. Unforeseen developments such as customer demands, competitor movements, or developments in the overall market will render pieces of the plan unattainable, or even irrelevant.

Download Onion Browser App for Free

Individual contributors quite often sit very close to the core and tend to look from the insisde outwards. Their focus is on practices that are usually quite quickly and clearly visible. Whereas traditionally managers sit on the outer layers of this system and look through those towards the inside.

Related Posts

7 Phases of the System Development Life Cycle Guide

These companies may dedicate teams of individuals to managing the software lifecycle in a way that supports the client company based on discovery and participation. Iterative and incremental practices led to prototyping in the 1980s, which led to various different...


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *